Cheddars – Marcella The Cheesemonger International Guilde des Fromagers
Read My Latest Blog Entry


Flagship Reserve Display in the Kiosk

Flagship Reserve Display

Updated 1/18/2015

Cheddar cheese which originated in the Southwestern English Village of Cheddar is traditionally a semi-firm to hard cheese. In England, the cheesemakers wrap the truckles (Denotes a cheese wheel that is taller than it is wide) in cheesecloth and smear with lard before the aging begins.

To be a true cheddar, an additional step in the cheesemaking process is necessary, which is called “cheddaring”. After separating the curds from the whey, the curds are kneaded with salt and formed into large, long  blocks. The blocks are cut and stacked on top of each of each other, which expels more whey. This can be done several times to remove more and more whey, depending on how dry the cheesemaker wants his/her finished product.

After cheddaring, the curds are milled and put into hoops/forms to begin the aging process. The longer the cheese is aged, the more distinct the flavor.

Usually a mild cheddar is no more than 4 months old; medium is aged up to 8 months. Any cheddar aged 9 months is considered “sharp” or full-flavored.

Cheese Index    165 Cheeses You Should Know   281 Cheeses You Should Know   Raw Milk Cheeses   Vegetarian Suitable Cheeses   English Protected Cheeses   European Union Protected Cheeses   French Protected Cheeses   Greek Protected Cheeses   Italian Protected Cheeses   Portuguese Protected Cheeses   Spanish Protected Cheeses   Swiss Protected Cheeses


Appel Farm Cheddar with Black Peppercorns

Appel Farm Sharp Cheddar 

Appleby’s Cheshire from Neal’s Yard

Appleby’s Double Gloucester

Applewood Smoked Cheddar (Ilchester) 

Ballard Family’s Idaho White Cheddar 

Bandaged Cheddar (Fiscalini)

Barber’s 1833 

Barely Buzzed (Beehive Cheese Company) 

Beecher’s Cheese Curds

Beecher’s Extra Aged Flagship

Beecher’s Flagsheep

Beecher’s Flagship

Beecher’s Flagship Raw

Beecher’s Flagship Reserve

Beecher’s Flagship Reserve Raw

Beecher’s Marco Polo 

Beecher’s Market-Herbed Cheddar Curds

Beecher’s No Woman

Beecher’s Smoked Flagship

Beehive Cheese Company’s Barely Buzzed 

Beer Cheese (Ilchester) 

Black Creek Cheddar

Black Diamond Extra Sharp White Cheddar 

Black Mountain 

Blarney Castle (Kerrygold) 

Blue Mont Bandaged Cheddar 

Borough Market Farmhouse Cheddar (Mary Quicke)

Boxing Cheddar from Australia 

Bravo Farms Premium Cheddar *

Brunkow’s Green Olive White Cheddar 

Cabot’s Aged Cheddar 

Cabot’s Clothbound Cheddar from the Cellars at Jasper Hill 

Cabot’s Farmer’s Legacy Cheddars

Cabot’s Vintage Choice Cheddar 

Cahill’s Original Irish Porter Cheese

Cahill’s Whiskey Cheddar 

Cantalet (This cheddar is made in France…)

Carr Valley Apple Smoked Cheddar

Carr Valley Garlic Cheddar

Carr Valley Horseradish Cheddar

Carr Valley Ten-Year Cheddar

Carr Valley Wildflower Cheddar 

Cheddar Curds (Beecher’s)

Cheese Curds (Really Fresh) – Beecher’s

Cheese Curds (Beecher’s Handmade Cheese)

Cheese Curds (Ellsworth Co-op Creamery)

Cheese Curds (Golden Age Cheese Company)

Cheese Curds (Tillamook) 

Chevre Noir (Fromagerie Tournevant – Quebec, Canada)

Chocolate Stout Cheddar (Rogue Creamery)

Collier’s Powerful Welsh Cheddar 

Coastal Cheddar (Ford Farm)

Cotswold Pub Cheese

Cougar Gold – yep, this is a cheese in a can… and you don’t spray it on a cracker…

Denhay Farmhouse Cheddar 

DiBruno Brothers Horseradish and Bacon Cheddar Spread 

DiBruno Brothers Horseradish and Bacon Cheddar Spread (ACS Profile)

Dorset Red (Ford Farm)

Double Gloucester

Dubliner (Kerrygold) 

Ellsworth Co-op Creamery Cheddar Cheese Curds

Ellsworth Co-op Creamery Natural Cheese Curds

Ellsworth Co-op Creamery Ranch Cheese Curds

English Huntsman

Excalibur English Cheddar

Extra Sharp Cheddar (Golden Age Cheese Company) 

Face Rock Original Cheese Curds

Face Rock In Your Face Curds

Face Rock Jalapeno Cheese Curds

Farmer’s Reserve (Westminster) 

Farmhouse Cheddar from Mary Quicke

Fiscalini Farmstead Bandaged Cheddar

Fiscalini Farmstead Premium Aged Cheddar 

Fiscalini Farmstead Traditional Bandaged Cheddar

Fiscalini Vintage Bandaged Cheddar (ACS Profile)


Flagship (Beechers)

Flagship Curds 

Flagship, Extra Aged

Flagship Raw

Flagship Reserve

Flagship Reserve Raw

Flagship, Smoked

Ford Farm Coastal Cheddar

Ford Farm Smoked Red Dorset

Garlic Chili Pepper Cheddar (Tillamook)

Golden Age Cheese Company Cheddar Cheese Curds

Golden Age Cheese Company Extra Sharp Cheddar

Golden Age Cheese Company Super Sharp Cheddar

Golden Glen Creamery Medium Cheddar with Sweet Basil

Golden Glen Creamery Medium Cheddar with Red Pepper, Onion and Garlic

Golden Glen Creamery Medium Cheddar with Garlic and Dill

Golden Glen Creamery 4-Year Cheddar: Aidan’s Reserve

Golden Glen Creamery River Cheddar 

Gothberg Farms Aged Cheddar

Grafton Village Cheese 2 Year Cheddar 

Grafton Village 4 Year Raw Milk Cheddar 

Grafton  Village Clothbound Cheddar

Great Lakes Cheshire

Great Ocean Road Cheddar

Green Olive White Cheddar (Brunkows)

Green’s of Glastonbury Organic Mature Cheddar

Hard Goat Cheddar

Henning’s Aged Natural Peppercorn Cheddar

Henning’s Blueberry Cobbler Cheddar

Henning’s Mango Fire Cheddar

Henning’s Mediterranean Sunset Cheddar

Henning’s Peppercorn Cheddar

Henning’s 10-Year Cheddar 

Hoffman’s Vermont White Cheddar

Horseradish Cheddar (Tillamook)

Idaho White Cheddar (Ballard Family)

Ilchester Beer Cheese

Ilchester Smoked Applewood 

In Your Face Curds

Irish Cheddar (Mature, Tuxford and Tebbutts) 

Isle of Man Mature Cheddar

Ivy’s Vintage Reserve Cheddar (Wyck Farms)

Kerrygold Aged Cheddar

Kerrygold Dubliner

Kerrygold Red Leicester

Kirkland’s Signature Cave-Aged Vermont Cheddar (Costco)

Laack’s Eight Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Lavender Cheddar (Rogue Creamery) 

Lighter Cheddar (Tuxford and Tebbutts)

Lincolnshire Poacher from Neal’s Yard

Londoner Cheddar

Marco Polo (Beechers) 

Mature Irish Cheddar (Tuxford and Tebbutts) 

Mary Quicke’s Borough Raw Milk Bandaged Cheddar

Mary Quicke’s Farmhouse Cheddar

Mary Quicke’s Oak-Smoked Cheddar 

Milton Creamery’s Prairie Breeze 

Montgomery Cheddar

Moon Cheese

Neighborly Farms’ Organic Sharp Cheddar 

Neighborly Farm’s Sharp Cheddar

Oak-Smoked Cheddar (Mary Quicke’s)

Old Croc – 18 month Australian Cheddar

Pilgrim’s Choice Londoner Cheddar 

Pineland Farm’s One Year Sharp Cheddar

Pistol Point (Rogue Creamery)

Prairie Breeze 

Quicke’s Oak-Smoked Cheddar

Red Dragon

Rogue Creamery Chocolate Stout Cheddar 

Rogue Creamery Hopyard Cheddar

Rogue Creamery Lavender Cheddar 

Rogue Creamery’s Pistol Point

Rogue Creamery Raw Milk Sharp Cheddar 

Royal Addition Cheddar 

Royal Addition Cheddar 2014

Saxon Creamery Pastures

Shelburne Farms’ Farmhouse 2 Year Cheddar

Smoked Flagship 

Sonoma Creamery 4 Year Raw Milk Cheddar

Spring Hills Organic Jersey Cheese Curds

Super Sharp Cheddar (Golden Age Cheese Company)

Tillamook Cheese Curds

Tillamook Flavored Cheeses

Tillamook 100th Anniversary Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar Wheel

Tillamook Vintage Extra White Sharp Cheddar


Tuxford and Tebbutts’ Mature Irish Cheddar 

Vintage Bandaged Cheddar from Fiscalini (ACS Profile)

Washington State University’s Cougar Gold 

Wensleydale (Hawes Creamery) 

Westminster Farmer’s Reserve 

Westminster’s Royal Addition 2013

Whiskey Cheddar (Cahill’s)

Wildflower Cheddar (Carr Valley)

Wisconsin’s Black Creek Cheddar

Wyck Farm’s Ivy Vintage Reserve Cheddar


%d bloggers like this: