Cheddar Cheese Reviews

I grew up on Cheddar and it remains a mainstay at The Manse – there are always several cheddars in our fridge. The Man loves Cheddar.

These are the cheddars I have reviewed since Spaulding Gray (RIP) and I began this blog in 2008 (136 and counting as of 12/2021):

• Rogue Creamery Cheddars: Rogue’s Mary, Whoa Nellie, Jefferson Cheddar – 2021 Reviews
• Organic Double Gloucester – 2021 Review
• Tillamook Cheddar Platter Selection – 2021 Review
• Vermont’s Billings Farm Smoked Cheddar – 2019 Review
• Vermont’s Billings Farm Sweet Cheddar – 2019 Review
• Vermont’s Billings Farm Butter Cheddar – 2019 Review
• Vermont’s Billings Farm Woodstock Reserve Cheddar – 2019 Review
• Southern Origin Legacy Red Mead Cheese – 2020 Review
• Southern Origin Wildflower Mead Cheese – 2020 Review
• Southern Origin Pollinator Pyment Mead Cheese – 2020 Review
• Southern Origin Black Currant Mead Cheese – 2020 Review
• Hafod Cheddar – 2020 Review
• Montgomery Cheddar – 2020 Review
• Isle of Mull Cheddar – 2020 Review
• Lincolnshire Poacher – 2020 Review
• Sheep Milk Cheddar – Wisconsin Sheep Dairy Coop  2017 Review
• Cabot 3-Year Cheddar at 2017 Blue Haven Bee Tasting
• Cabot 3-Year Cheddar 2017 Review
• Cabot 3-Year Cheddar 2017 Mead Pairings
• Widmer’s 4-year Cheddar 2018 Cheeselandia Event
• Cabot Clothbound Cheddar – 2018 CiderCraft Magazine Pairings
• Beecher’s Flagsheep 2018 American Cheese Month
• Specialty Cheeses for Purchase
• Quicke’s Cheddar 2017 Review
• Trivium Goat Cheddar 2017 Review
• Cabot Clothbound Cheddar 2017 Review
• West Country Farmhouse Cheddar PDO 2017 Review
• Flagsheep 2017 Review
• Flagship 2017 Review
• Prairie Breeze 2016 Review
• Vermont Farmstead Ale House Cheddar 2016 Review
• Facerock Creamery  Clothbound Cheddar 2016 Review
• Montgomery Cheddar 2015 Review
• Alpine Cheddar 2014 Review
• Farmhouse Reserve 2014 Review
• White Oak Cheddar 2014 Review
• Mull of Kintyre Scottish Cheddar 2015 Review
• Vintage Bandage Cheddar – Fiscalini 2014 Review
• Grafton Village Clothbound Cheddar 2014 Review
• Tillamook 2 Year Vintage Extra Sharp White Cheddar 2014 Review
• Royal Addition 1 Year Cheddar 2014 Review
• Grafton Village Clothbound Cheddar 2014 Review
• Appel Farms Sharp Cheddar 2014 Review
• Appel Farms Cheddar with Pepper 2014 Review
• Sonoma Creamery 4 Year Raw Milk White Cheddar 2014 Review
• Ivey’s Vintage Reserve Cheddar – Wyck Farms 2014 Review
• Blue Mont Bandaged Cheddar 2014 Review
• Grafton Village 4 Year Raw Milk Cheddar
• Prairie Breeze 2014 Review
• Old Croc 2014 Review
• Borough Market Farmhouse Cheddar 2014 Review
• Fiscalini Bandaged Cheddar 2013 Review
• Vintage Choice Cheddar – Cabot Coop – 2013 Review
• Grafton 2 Year Cheddar 203 Review
• Shelburne 2 Year Cheddar 2013 Review
• Sharp Cheddar – neighborly Farms 2013 Review
• White Cheddar – Ballard Family Cheese 2013 Review
• William and Kate Royal Addition Cheddar 2013 Review
• Tickler Mature Cheddar 2013 Review
• Barber’s 1833 West Country Cheddar PDO 2013 Review
• Pineland’s 1-year Sharp Cheddar 2013 Review
• Black Creek Cheddar 2012 Review
• Flagship 2012 Review
• Flagship – Daelia’s Cheese Plate 2012 Review
• Flagsheep – Daelia’s Cheese Plate 2012 Review
• Flagship Raw – 2012 Review
• Flagship Reserve 2012 Review
• Pistol Point Chipolte 2012 Review
• Quicke’s Oak-soaked Cheddar 2012 Review
• Tuxford and Tebbett’s Mature Irish Cheddar 2012 Review
• Lighter Cheddar from Tuxford and Tebbett
• Flagsheep NYE Platter 2012 Review
• Golden Glen Creamery River Cheddar 2011 Review
• Flagsheep 2011 Review
• Mrs. Quickes’ Clothbound Cheddar 2011 Review
• Grafton 2-year Extra Sharp Cheddar 2011 Review
• Rogue Creamery Raw, Sharp Cheddar 2011 Review
• Hopyard 2011 Review
• Collier’s Powerful Welsh Cheddar
• Cabot Creamery 2-Year Cheddar 2011 Review Murray’s Cheese Boot Camp
• Cabot Clothbound Cheddar 2011 Review Murray’s Cheese Boot Camp
• Cahill’s Whiskey Cheddar 2011 Review
• Ford Farms Red Dorset 2011 Review
• Tintern 2011 Review
• Red Dragon 2011 Review
• Black Mountain 2011 Review
• Greens of Glastonbury Organic Mature Cheddar 2011 Review
• Kirkland Signature Clothbound Cheddar 2011 Review
• Excalibur English Cheddar 2010 Review
• Australian Boxing Cheddar 2010 Review
• Flagship Raw 2010 Review
• Isle of Man Mature Cheddar 2010 Review
• Hoffman White Vermont Cheddar 2010 Review
• Smoked Flagship 2010 Review
• Flagsheep 2010 Review
• Extra Aged Flagship 2010 Review
• Laack’s 8-Year Extra Sharp Cheddar 2010 Review
• Carr Valley 10-year Cheddar 2010 Review
• Carr Valley Horseradish Cheddar 2010 Review
• Gothberg Farms’ Aged Goat Cheddar 2010 Review
• Black Diamond Extra Sharp Black Cheddar 2010 Review
• Golden Glen Creamery Flavored Cheddars 2010 Review
• Golden Glen Creamery Aiden’s Reserve 2010 Review
• Hennings 10-year Cheddar 2010 Review
• Henning’s Mediterranean Cheddar 2010 Review
• Henning’s Aged Natural Peppercorn Cheddar 2010 Review
• Blueberry Heritage Aged Cheddar 2010 Review
• Henning’s Mango Fire Cheddar 2010 Review
• Carr Valley’s Apple Smoked Cheddar 2010 Review
• Carr Valley’s Garlic Cheddar 2010 Review
• River Cheddar 2010 Review
• Carr Valley’s Wildflower Cheddar 2010 Review
• TouVelle from Rogue Creamery 2010 Review
• Lavender Cheddar from Rogue Creamery 2010 Review
• Chocolate Stout Cheddar from Rogue Creamery 2010 Review
• Jim’s Pantry’s Green Olive Cheddar 2010 Review 
• Ford Farm’s Mature Coastal Cheddar 2009 Review
• Fiscalini Farmstead Premium Aged Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Peppercorn Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Smoked Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Horseradish Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar 2009 Review
• Cougar Gold 2009 Review
• Golden Age Extra Sharp Cheddar 2009 Review
• Golden Age Super Sharp Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook 100th Anniversary Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Garlic chili Pepper Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Horseradish Cheddar 2009 Review
• Denhay Farmhouse Cheddar 2009 Review
• Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar 2009 Review
• Cahill’s Original Irish Porter Cheddar 2009 Review
• Flagship Reserve 2009 Review
• Kerrygold Aged Cheddar 2009 Review
• Kerrygold Dubliner 2009 Review
• Hard Goat’s Cheddar 2009 Review
• Applewood Smoky Cheddar 2009 Review
• Flagship 2008 Review
• Marco Polo 2008 Review
• No Woman 2008 Review

In addition to being an American Cheese Society Certified Cheese Professional, I am a Certified ServSafe Food Production Manager with certifications that also include ServSafe Certified Instructor and Proctor. I am available for cheese events, cheese program development, cheese training, food safety training and 3rd party food safety auditing. See my About Me and Resume pages for more details or call me at 360 921 9908 to discuss availability.

As an authorized Amazon Influencer, there are affiliate links within this posting which can result in income for me. Please visit my Amazon Storefront; your support contributes to the overhead required to keep this website alive and updated.

Follow me on:

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
•